If you’ve spent the last few years searching for a game that captures the magic of Animal Crossing and the deep crafting loops of My Time at Sandrock, you’ve likely had Starsand Island on your radar. After months of anticipation and a massive 600,000+ wishlists on Steam, this Ghibli-inspired life sim has finally landed in Early Access on Xbox Series X|S.

But does this “Star of the Deep Sea” shine brightly on console, or is it still a diamond in the rough? Here is my deep dive into the Xbox version of Starsand Island.