If you’ve ever spent a Saturday afternoon surrounded by the neon glow of a Dave & Buster’s or a seaside boardwalk arcade, The Coin Game will feel instantly familiar. Developed by the solo dev at devotid and recently brought to Xbox by publisher Kwalee, this title is less of a traditional “game” and more of a comprehensive arcade-and-carnival simulator.

After spending time across its neon-soaked island, here is a balanced look at whether this ticket-redemption sandbox is worth your digital quarters.